| Year | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 11 | 1-1 Ruth Bader Ginsburg | 2-1 Vinny Gambini | 3-2 Lt. Daniel Kaffee | 4-1 Robert Volpe |
| Year 12 | 1-4 Frank Serpico | 2-1 Melvin Purvis | None | 4-1 Officer Lockstock |
| Year 13 | 1-4 Johnnie Cochran | 2-3 Alan Dershowitz | None | 4-1 Raymond Kelly |
| Year 14 | 1-2 Louis Brandeis | None | None | 4-2 Gloria Allred 4-4 Ozzie Walls |
| Year 15 | 1-14 Jack McCoy | None | 3-16 Joseph Pistone | 4-5 Clarice Starling 4-9 John McBain 4-14 Franklin Dodge |
| Year 16 | None | 2-12 F. Lee Bailey | 3-9 Robert Kardashian 3-11 Frank Pembleton | 4-13 Garry McCarthy |
| Year 17 | None | 2-13 Rusty Hardin | 3-15 Felix Frankfurter | 4-15 Joseph Story |
| Year | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 17 | 1-9 Casper the Friendly Ghost | None | 3-9 Wrinkly Kong | 4-2 Malcolm Crowe 4-8 Kyra Collins |
| Year | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 2 | 1-3 Corak 1-6 Roger Wilco | 2-10 Elaine Marley | None | 4-7 Elik the Great |
| Year 3 | 1-3 Arthur Dent | 2-11 Eric the Unready | 3-8 Warrax the Chaos Warrior | None |
| Year 4 | 1-5 Christopher "Bluehair" Blair | 2-6 Spark 2-12 Commander Keen | 3-8 King Midas | 4-4 Zoranthus |
| Year 5 | None | 2-2 Ak'shel | None | None |
| Year 6 | 1-5 Tanya Adams | None | None | None |
| Year 7 | None | None | 3-1 Doctor Blood | 4-3 Laura Bow |
| Year 8 | 1-1 Kien "Bossman" Chen | 2-1 Cedric the Owl | 3-2 Dogmeat | 4-1 Fall-From-Grace |
| Year 9 | 1-2 Griswold the Blacksmith | 2-2 Hawkslayer | 3-1 Irkalla | 4-1 Catherine Ironfist |
| Year 10 | 1-1 Jaheira | 2-2 Queen Kalindra | 3-1 Kilmor | 4-2 Loknar the Last Orion |